Monmouth GuideWhere to eat in Tinton Falls, NJ
11 restaurants, cafes and bars, hand-picked.
11 places to eat and drink in Tinton Falls, Monmouth County, picked and described by Monmouth Guide. For events, beaches and parks, see things to do in Tinton Falls.
Restaurants in Tinton Falls
-
Gargiulo's Tinton Falls
Italian (Neapolitan) · Sister to Brooklyn's famous Gargiulo'sOffshoot of the long-running Coney Island institution, serving classic Neapolitan Italian dishes from the Russo family.
-
Golden Horn Restaurant
Turkish / Mediterranean · One of the top-rated restaurants in Tinton Falls on review sitesFamily-friendly Turkish and Mediterranean spot on Route 66 known for kebabs, fresh-baked bread and generous platters.
-
Jimmy Pecci's Taste of Italy
Italian deli & market · Local favorite for Italian subs; second shop at 4060 Asbury AveGourmet Italian market and deli since 1996, beloved for heroes on brick-oven bread and prepared Italian dishes.
-
Nino's Bistro Express
Pizza / Sicilian Italian · Tomato pie recognized by NJ.comFamily-run Sicilian spot known for coal-fired and Grandma pizzas, award-winning wings and arancini.
-
The Pour House
American pub · Prime rib nights and daily dinner specialsFamily-owned neighborhood pub for nearly 30 years, known for nightly steak, prime rib and lobster specials and a patio with TVs.
-
Anna's Restaurant
American (family dining)Family-style restaurant serving all-day breakfast plus lunch and dinner entrees at affordable prices.
-
Apple Street Kitchen
Farm-to-Table AmericanFarm-to-table brunch spot on a one-acre property with its own organic garden, market and cooking classroom.
-
CJ McLoone's Pub and Grille
AmericanFamily-friendly American tavern with a separate dining room, a TV-filled pub and weekend brunch.
-
Dom's Cherry Street Deli
DeliFourth-generation family deli open since 1985, known for signature sandwiches, cheesesteaks and homemade specials.
-
Nettie's House of Spaghetti
Italian-AmericanModern take on the red-sauce joint, with Italian-American classics alongside plant-based dishes; dinner only, reservations via Resy.
-
Tally Ho Restaurant
Italian / AmericanLocally owned since 1995, serving Northern Italian pasta, seafood and steaks with a full bar in a family-friendly setting.
Quick answers
Where should I eat in Tinton Falls, NJ?
Local picks include Gargiulo's Tinton Falls, Golden Horn Restaurant and Jimmy Pecci's Taste of Italy. This guide lists 11 places to eat and drink in Tinton Falls, including italian (neapolitan), turkish / mediterranean, italian deli & market, pizza / sicilian italian, american pub and american (family dining).