Where to eat in Colts Neck, NJ

13 restaurants, cafes and bars, hand-picked.

13 places to eat and drink in Colts Neck, Monmouth County, picked and described by Monmouth Guide. For events, beaches and parks, see things to do in Colts Neck.

Restaurants in Colts Neck

Colts Neck Inn Steakhouse

Steakhouse · Repeatedly voted Monmouth County's best steakhouse by Asbury Park Press readers

Historic inn dating to 1717, family-owned since 1973 and famous for hand-cut steaks and prime rib, now with sushi and a raw bar after a renovation.
Colts Neck General Store & Deli

Deli

General store and deli on Route 537, a local stop for breakfast sandwiches, burgers and chicken sandwiches.
Deli Delight

Deli

Colts Neck deli known for fresh, flavorful sandwiches, with the egg sandwich a regular highlight.
Gianni's Colts Neck Pizza

Pizza

Family-owned pizzeria at The Orchards plaza, part of a local group serving Monmouth County for over 30 years.
Huddy's Inn

American tavern

Historic tavern-style gathering spot serving classic American fare, with a late-night bar menu.
Orlando Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Italian

BYOB Italian restaurant and pizzeria on Route 34 serving pizza and traditional Italian dishes.
Prima Pizza

Pizza / Italian

Family-owned pizzeria best known for its Grandma pie with a buttery, crispy crust.
Via Sposito

Italian

Flagship of a local Italian group, known for fresh daily mozzarella, house-made pasta, coal-fired pizza and dry-aged steaks.

Coffee, bakeries & sweets in Colts Neck

Delicious Orchards

Bakery & country market · Monmouth County institution for pies and cider donuts

Beloved country market with an on-premises scratch bakery famous for seasonal fruit pies and apple cider donuts.
Rook Coffee (Colts Neck)

Coffee

Colts Neck shop of the Monmouth County specialty coffee roaster, in the Orchards Plaza.

Bars, breweries & wineries in Colts Neck

4JG's Orchards & Vineyards

An estate winery whose tasting room sits in a 1700s farmhouse, with picnics allowed on the vineyard grounds.
Colts Neck Pub

American

Neighborhood pub and sports bar on Route 34 known for calamari, loaded fries and buffalo chicken sliders.
Source Farmhouse Brewery

Craft beer

Farm brewery pouring farm-to-glass ales and lagers brewed on site, with a Bavarian-style biergarten and picnic areas.

Quick answers

Where should I eat in Colts Neck, NJ?

Local picks include Colts Neck Inn Steakhouse, Delicious Orchards and 4JG's Orchards & Vineyards. This guide lists 13 places to eat and drink in Colts Neck, including steakhouse, bakery & country market, deli, american, pizza and american tavern.