Where to eat in Belmar, NJ

17 restaurants, cafes and bars, hand-picked.

17 places to eat and drink in Belmar, Monmouth County, picked and described by Monmouth Guide. For events, beaches and parks, see things to do in Belmar.

Restaurants in Belmar

Federici's on 10th

Italian · Federici family pizza, four generations

Belmar outpost of the century-old Federici family, known for thin-crust brick-oven pizza and Italian classics.
Federico's Pizza & Restaurant

Pizza · Classic Jersey Shore pizza

Belmar pizza institution on Main Street for about 30 years, serving crisp-crust pies, pasta and sandwiches.
Hoagitos

Sandwiches · Featured in New Jersey Monthly

Sandwich shop that grew from an Asbury boardwalk pop-up, known for small gourmet hoagies and fried chicken sandwiches on house-roasted meats.
Klein's Fish Market & Waterside Cafe

Seafood · Belmar seafood institution on the water

Family-run fish market and waterside cafe on the Shark River serving fresh local seafood, sushi and a tiki bar with marina views.
La Dolce Vita

Italian · Ocean views across from the beach

Family-owned Italian restaurant since 1980, directly across from Belmar Beach with ocean-view porch dining.
Los Barbaros Birria

Mexican · Known for birria tacos

Taqueria specializing in birria tacos with consommé for dipping, plus birria pizza and ramen.
Pizzeria 'Lucci

Pizza · One of NJ's most-praised pizzerias

Small Neapolitan-style pizzeria widely ranked among the best pies in New Jersey, known for its white pie and housemade meatballs.
WindMill Hot Dogs (Belmar)

Hot Dogs & Burgers · Shore staple since 1964

Jersey Shore hot dog chain dating to 1964, known for big grilled franks with snap and cheese fries.
10th Ave Burrito Co.

Mexican

Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives-featured Mexi-Cali spot with a patio, weekend brunch and free live music on weekends.
Anchor Tavern

American

Main Street tavern known for wood-fired rotisserie chicken and late-night bites, with an outdoor patio.
Marina Grille

Seafood

Large waterfront restaurant on the Shark River at the Belmar Marina with deck seating, a tiki bar and dock-and-dine access.
Mike's Giant Submarines

Deli / Subs

Old-school Belmar sub shop making fresh, generously stuffed hoagies to order.
Mr. Greek

Greek

Casual Greek and Mediterranean spot praised for its gyro platters and house tzatziki.

Coffee, bakeries & sweets in Belmar

Turnstile Coffee Roasters

Coffee · House-roasted coffee

Family-owned specialty coffee shop roasting small batches in-house since 2011, a mile from the beach.
Caffè di Famiglia

Italian Bakery & Cafe

Italian-style cafe with traditional pastries, coffee, breakfast waffle sandwiches and Italian street sandwiches.
Corner Bagelry (Belmar)

Bagels & Deli

Local bagel shop serving homemade bagels, crumb cake and Boar's Head sandwiches since 1994 (Belmar shop since 2013).

Bars, breweries & wineries in Belmar

Beach Haus Brewery

Brewpub

Downtown Belmar brewery in the former Freedman's Bakery with 20 taps, a full food menu and a rooftop bar.

Quick answers

Where should I eat in Belmar, NJ?

Local picks include Federici's on 10th, Federico's Pizza & Restaurant and Hoagitos. This guide lists 17 places to eat and drink in Belmar, including italian, pizza, sandwiches, seafood, mexican and coffee.