Fresh

American, mediterranean-leaning in Highlands, New Jersey · $$$

Chef-driven bistro on Bay Avenue known for seafood pastas, grilled octopus and scallops.

Why go: Rated 4.8 across 150+ reviews

Visiting Fresh

• Address144 Bay Ave, Highlands, NJ 07732
• Phone732-708-0328
• Websitefreshhighlands.com
• Price$$$
• Typical visitAbout 1.8 hours
• Good forDate, friends, seniors
• VibeUpscale
• ServesDinner
• Indoors?Indoor
• Last checked2026-09-25

More to do in Highlands

• Bahrs Landing

  seafood

  Family-run seafood restaurant and marina at the foot of the Route 36 bridge, serving lobster and seafood since 1917.

• Porcini

  italian

  Intimate Italian restaurant on Bay Avenue with indoor dining, seasonal outdoor seating and takeout.

• One Willow

  seafood, raw bar

  Waterfront seafood and raw bar restaurant with dock-and-dine boat access.

• The Seafarer

  american, bar food

  Waterfront beach bar with fire pits, couches by the water and frequent live bands.

• Proving Ground

  seafood, american

  Big waterfront restaurant and tiki bar on the Shrewsbury River, open late every day.

• Off The Hook

  seafood, american

  Casual restaurant and bar at the Route 36 bridge, next to the water.

Quick answers

More: things to do in Highlands · Highlands news · best of Monmouth County.