Big City Sandwiches

Sandwiches in Eatontown, New Jersey · $

Family-owned shop recreating iconic sandwiches from U.S. cities, from NYC chopped cheese to Chicago Italian beef.

Why go: Opened in 2025 and quickly became one of Eatontown's top-rated spots

Visiting Big City Sandwiches

Mauka Indian Cuisine
indian
Family-owned Indian restaurant on Route 35 serving lunch and dinner daily, with tandoori specialties and catering.
Ember & Eagle
italian steakhouse
Italian-inspired steakhouse in the historic TillingHouse at Suneagles Golf Club, with a raw bar and live music in the Parlor Bar.
Olivia's II Pizza & Pasta
pizza / italian
Popular Route 35 pizzeria known for Brooklyn pan pies, penne vodka pizza and hearty pasta and seafood dishes.
Belo Pizzeria
pizza / italian
Downtown Eatontown pizzeria dating to 1980, reborn under new owners with Jersey-style pies and a refreshed dining room.
Fumiyama Sushi
japanese / sushi
Highly rated Japanese spot praised for fresh sushi and sashimi, special rolls and hibachi dishes.
Rise N Shine Diner
breakfast / american
Old-school, family-run breakfast and lunch spot on Main Street known for made-from-scratch pancakes and friendly service.

115 Route 35, Eatontown, NJ 07724. It's in Eatontown, Monmouth County, New Jersey.

Expect $ prices.

Solo, friends, family. About 25 minutes is a typical visit.